Silent Hill: Townfall Is Good. The PC Port Has Other Ideas
SILENT HILL: Townfall is out now, and the first 24 hours have produced a very awkward little situation: the game itself appears to be good, while the PC version is currently behaving like it has been possessed by a radiator.
Townfall launched September 24 on PS5, Steam and the Epic Games Store. Professional reviews have been broadly positive about its atmosphere, story, puzzles and beautifully miserable Scottish island.
Steam players are having a rather different holiday.
As of September 25, Townfall sits at Mixed on Steam, with 67% positive reviews from 1,162 users, and a big chunk of the anger is aimed squarely at performance. Players are reporting traversal stutter, hitching and crashes, including on pretty serious hardware. Screen Burn Interactive has already acknowledged the problems and confirmed that a performance patch is being worked on.
There is no date for that patch yet.
So this is where Townfall currently lives: critics seem to like the horror game, PC players are fighting the horror software, and somewhere somebody responsible for frame pacing has probably gone very quiet.
If miserable towns, terrible life choices and things breathing where they absolutely shouldn’t are your recreational activity, Halloween: The Game is waiting down the next corridor. Michael Myers has somehow made property values even worse.
Townfall Is Actually a Proper Silent Hill Game
Any lingering fear that Townfall might turn out to be three hours of staring at an old television while somebody whispers about grief can probably be buried.
You play Simon Ordell, returning to the fictional Scottish island of St. Amelia and slowly digging into his connection to whatever appalling thing happened there. Because this is Silent Hill, he has obviously not gone back because someone told him the pub reopened.
Townfall is a first-person psychological survival-horror game built around exploration, environmental puzzles, stealth, limited combat and resource pressure.
The big toy is a handheld CRTV, an analogue television that can reveal signals, clues, story fragments and enemy locations. On paper, that sounds dangerously close to one of those mechanics that gets shown in every trailer, everybody goes “that’s clever”, and then six hours later the game quietly shoves it in a drawer next to detective vision and protagonists who can repair industrial electrical systems after finding one screwdriver.
But apparently it actually matters.
The CRTV feeds into puzzles, exploration and enemy awareness, although completed reviews suggest it becomes less important later on.
The puzzles themselves seem to be one of Townfall’s stronger ideas. They are often built into believable places and objects instead of arriving as giant videogame puzzle shrines clearly installed by Satan’s facilities department.
And that matters for Silent Hill.
A normal house that starts behaving incorrectly is disturbing.
A room containing twelve ceremonial skulls, rotating statues and a blood-covered combination lock is basically admitting defeat.
Townfall seems to understand the difference.
The Horror Is Landing Better Than the Fighting
The strongest early praise is landing exactly where it needs to.
The Scottish setting is getting a lot of love. Townfall leans into bleak coastlines, fog, domestic spaces, isolation and decaying architecture without simply photocopying Silent Hill 2 until the toner catches fire.
The story and environmental storytelling are also being received well, particularly the way Simon’s personal nightmare opens out into the wider history of St. Amelia.
Then somebody hands the man a weapon.
This appears to be where things get wobblier.
Townfall has melee weapons and limited firearms, plus opportunities to hide from or distract enemies, but combat and enemy variety keep coming up as weaker parts of the game.
That is always dangerous territory for survival horror.
A monster stops being frightening surprisingly quickly once the player starts mentally filing it under problem requiring pipe.
Monster appears.
Check ammo.
Apply pipe.
Continue to cupboard.
That is not existential terror.
That is pest control with trauma.
Townfall seems much happier when it is making you explore, investigate, interpret and worry than when it asks you to physically negotiate with whatever horrible damp thing has wandered into the corridor.
Which, frankly, is probably where Silent Hill should live anyway.
Steam Has Discovered Another Kind of Horror
Then there is the PC version.
Townfall’s Steam reception is currently much colder than its professional reviews, and the performance problems are sitting right in the middle of that argument wearing steel-toe boots.
Reports of traversal stutter, shader-related hitching and crashes have become common enough that Screen Burn has already responded officially.
A performance patch is coming.
That acknowledgement saves us from the usual launch-day circus where fourteen Reddit threads, three YouTube frame graphs and a man called xXGPUDESTROYERXx spend six hours deciding whether the problem technically exists.
The developer says there is a problem.
Good. Case closed.
What we do not know yet is how much the patch will fix, or when it is arriving.
And it would be dishonest to blame Townfall’s entire Mixed rating on performance. Steam reviews also contain complaints about combat, price and length.
But the technical problems are clearly serious enough to drag the PC launch into the mud.
Which creates a wonderfully stupid bit of thematic consistency.
Silent Hill is a series about reality becoming unstable, familiar spaces turning hostile and basic movement becoming stressful.
Apparently the PC version decided to participate.
Still hungry for horror that looks deeply unhealthy to investigate? Go meet Rehaunted, where apparently seeing one nightmare through to the end wasn’t enough punishment for today.
So Is Townfall Actually Bad?
Right now, it does not look like it.
The early picture is of a good psychological-horror game with an excellent setting, strong atmosphere, interesting puzzles and a story people are taking seriously.
The obvious weak spots are combat and limited enemy variety.
And on PC, performance.
That last one is not a footnote.
If you buy a horror game and the game stutters every time you cross a room, it does not really matter how beautifully designed the room is. The room is now a slideshow.
You can absolutely have a brilliant game buried under technical problems.
Unfortunately, you still have to play through the technical problems to reach the brilliant game.
A Michelin-starred dinner fired at your face through a leaf blower remains a compromised dining experience.
But there is an important distinction here.
Townfall’s launch currently looks much more like a promising Silent Hill game having a rough PC release than a fundamentally bad game finally being exposed by players.
That distinction may disappear if the patch changes nothing.
Or it may become the entire story if the Steam version suddenly starts behaving itself and people can focus on the actual game instead of watching frametime graphs perform cardiac arrhythmias.
So the next important thing for Townfall is not another review score.
It is the patch.
If Screen Burn can get the PC version under control, Townfall may finally get judged for the horror game sitting underneath all this technical noise.
Until then, the fog is not the biggest visibility problem on PC.
SILENT HILL: Townfall FAQ
Is SILENT HILL: Townfall out now?
Yes. SILENT HILL: Townfall launched on September 24, 2026 for PS5 and PC.
Is SILENT HILL: Townfall good?
Early professional reviews are broadly positive, especially about the atmosphere, Scottish setting, story and puzzles. Combat and enemy variety are getting a much rougher reception.
Why are Steam reviews Mixed?
A major reason is PC performance. Players have reported stuttering, hitching and crashes, although some reviews also criticise combat, price and length.
Is a SILENT HILL: Townfall performance patch coming?
Yes. Screen Burn Interactive has acknowledged the PC performance problems and confirmed that a patch is being worked on. There is currently no confirmed release date.
Should you wait before buying Townfall on PC?
If performance problems bother you, waiting for the first patch is the sensible move. Right now, the game underneath appears considerably healthier than the PC version carrying it around.
Comments