Dead by Daylight's Art the Clown: Five Weapons, Two Choices, One Bloody Lottery
Five weapons, two random choices and a bicycle horn that apparently qualifies as psychological warfare. Art the Clown has arrived in Dead by Daylight, but his greatest enemy might be his own rubbish bag.
Art the Clown's Bag of Toys is a wonderfully deranged Killer power with a genuine problem: the weapons are random, but the situations demanding them aren't. Dead by Daylight's Terrifier can shoot Survivors, dissolve them with acid, set their surroundings on fire and assault them with a flail. Unfortunately, he can't always decide which instrument of suffering comes out next.
The October 28 Public Test Build has already exposed questions about weapon reliability, counterplay and a progression system that can become strangely awkward as Art grows more dangerous. Community testing identifies specific concerns, although there isn't enough controlled match data to establish which combinations consistently outperform others. The potential is magnificent. The execution still needs scrutiny.
Art isn't the only Killer giving players headaches. Dead by Daylight's missing attack sounds can make successful hits feel like misses. Find out what's broken and whether there's a fix before blaming your aim on supernatural interference.
Five Weapons and the World's Least Reassuring Lucky Dip
Bag of Toys offers two randomly selected weapons from five possibilities: Acid Bottle, Flail, Handgun, Flamethrower and Bike Horn. Pick one, use it, and the bag enters cooldown. Acid creates hazardous puddles, the flail attacks over certain obstacles, the handgun provides ranged damage and the flamethrower can ignite pallets, windows and generators. The Bike Horn reveals Survivors through Killer Instinct and can extend existing Torture effects. Apparently, four instruments of grievous bodily harm weren't enough. Someone decided the murderous clown also needed a noise complaint.
The actual killing revolves around Torture. Hitting an injured Survivor with a damaging Toy applies the effect. Following up with a different Toy can down them and inflict Terrified, creating an opportunity to Taunt and improve Art's weapons through Deadliness. It's a clever premise because the weapons aren't interchangeable. Their different properties encourage Art to adapt to the environment. But there's a difference between improvising with a selection of tools and being handed whatever happens to be lying at the bottom of the bag.
When Randomness Stops Being Fun
Imagine chasing an injured Survivor towards a window. The flail might provide an attacking opportunity. A firearm could work if they're exposed. Acid might discourage a particular escape route. Now imagine opening the bag and receiving two options poorly suited to the situation. You still have a decision. It's just a decision between two things you didn't particularly want.
That's the gamble behind Art's design. A predictable Killer rewards mastery through repetition. Art demands knowledge of five weapons and the ability to recognise opportunities as they appear. Done properly, that's brilliant. Successful chases become something players assemble from unexpected circumstances. Done badly, randomness starts masquerading as difficulty.
Two choices provide some control, but their usefulness depends on positioning, terrain and Survivor behaviour. The available PTB reports don't establish how frequently unfortunate selections actually cost Art a down. There's enough evidence to question the mechanic, but not enough to convict it.
Prefer your murderous lunatics slightly smaller and considerably more foul-mouthed? Find out why Dead by Daylight is retiring Chucky, what existing owners keep and whether you need to buy him before November 24.
The Handgun Has Already Started an Argument
Art's handgun has attracted pointed criticism in Behaviour's official PTB feedback discussion. One player argued that it's considerably easier to land shots with keyboard and mouse than with a controller, suggesting that its apparent hitscan behaviour should be replaced with a fast projectile. Another complained about Survivors being hit despite appearing protected by cover.
These are individual reports, not independently verified defects, but they identify a genuine concern. A random weapon system becomes harder to balance when players believe effectiveness depends heavily on input method or inconsistent collision behaviour.
The flamethrower has provoked related criticism. One tester argued that Art prepares attacks too quickly, while the flamethrower threatens positions that might otherwise protect Survivors from his gun. Consider the predicament: you hide behind cover because a murderous clown is carrying a firearm. Sensible. He produces a flamethrower, and suddenly your excellent defensive plan resembles sheltering behind a garden fence during a volcanic eruption.
That could be fantastic horror design, provided Survivors have sufficient opportunities to respond. The strongest Killers make players feel hunted. Poor balancing makes them feel cheated.
Deadliness Has a Particularly Strange Problem
Each damaging Toy builds Deadliness through successful Torture applications. At maximum Deadliness, damaging weapons can down injured Survivors directly. Taunting a Terrified Survivor who's downed or hooked also improves the arsenal, encouraging combinations rather than repetitive attacks.
However, one PTB player reported that finishing certain combinations with an already-maxed weapon doesn't apply Terrified. Another agreed that this makes progressing the remaining weapons confusing. If accurate, improving one weapon can interfere with the combination that helps improve the others.
Congratulations. Your murder weapon has received a promotion and may now be less useful to your career development.
The interaction requires further confirmation, but it's a more meaningful criticism than simply declaring Art overpowered. Progression should reward mastery, not leave players wondering whether becoming more lethal has disrupted their next upgrade.
The Bike Horn Is Secretly Complicated
The Bike Horn sounds ridiculous, but it serves several strategic purposes. It detects Survivors, can apply Oblivious and resets active Torture timers. At maximum Deadliness, it can interrupt healing or generator repairs and regress their progress. Its value comes from supporting other weapons rather than directly injuring Survivors.
Unfortunately, Behaviour acknowledges that the PTB description omits an important requirement: detecting multiple Survivors is necessary for its Oblivious application and Deadliness gain. That's a significant omission in a system already demanding considerable mechanical understanding. Imagine discovering your bicycle horn has supernatural tactical properties, only to learn that those properties require a minimum audience. Apparently, even homicidal clowning has attendance requirements.
Incomplete descriptions also make weapon reliability difficult to judge. Players might expect an effect, fail to produce it and blame randomness when the actual problem is missing information.
Verdict: Brilliant Potential, Unfinished Rules
Art the Clown has the foundations of an unusually entertaining Killer. His weapons serve distinct purposes, Torture encourages varied attacks and Deadliness rewards successful aggression. The concept understands something important about playable monsters: the fantasy isn't simply being powerful. It's behaving in a way that feels distinctive. Art should feel like a lunatic who can turn almost anything into a weapon.
But community PTB testing raises credible questions about handgun targeting, flamethrower counterplay, Deadliness progression and incomplete descriptions. Those reports identify potential problems, not a proven hierarchy of weapon combinations. The central question of match-to-match reliability remains unanswered.
Behaviour needs to ensure that randomness encourages improvisation rather than repeatedly obstructing it. If a Survivor escapes after making an excellent play, that's Dead by Daylight. If they escape because Art reached for a flamethrower and pulled out a fucking bicycle horn, that's an entirely different horror story.
Had enough of relying on a clown's suspiciously stocked bag? Explore CRIMENET's playable villain headquarters, where monsters, murderers and criminal masterminds take centre stage. Being the bad guy has never suffered from a shortage of applicants.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does Art the Clown's Bag of Toys work?
Bag of Toys randomly offers two weapons from five possibilities: Acid Bottle, Flail, Handgun, Flamethrower and Bike Horn. Art selects one to use before the bag enters cooldown. Each weapon has different effects, encouraging players to adapt their attacks.
What are the best weapon combinations for Art the Clown?
There isn't enough reliable PTB testing to establish a definitive best combination. Damaging an injured Survivor with one Toy applies Torture, while following up with a different damaging Toy can down them. The most effective combinations depend on positioning, terrain and the weapons offered.
What does Deadliness do?
Deadliness improves Art's individual weapons through successful Torture applications. At maximum Deadliness, damaging Toys can down injured Survivors directly. Taunting Terrified Survivors who are downed or hooked also helps upgrade his arsenal.
Is Art the Clown overpowered in Dead by Daylight?
It's too early to say. PTB players have raised concerns about handgun targeting, flamethrower counterplay and weapon progression, but these reports don't establish that Art is overpowered. His balance may also change before the full release.
Comments