Mafia II: Definitive Edition Review: A Crime Masterpiece With One Big Problem
- Niels Gys
- 23 minutes ago
- 7 min read
Quick Verdict
Mafia II: Definitive Edition is absolutely worth playing if you want one of gaming’s best mafia stories, but do not expect a full criminal empire simulator.
You play as Vito Scaletta, a World War II veteran who returns home to Empire Bay and enters the Mafia to escape poverty, pay family debts, and chase a better life through extremely illegal career choices.
And by “better life” we mean the classic organised crime business plan:
Get nice suit.
Make dangerous friends.
Commit several felonies.
Act surprised when the other people committing felonies are not trustworthy.
Mafia II delivers the gangster fantasy through story, characters, atmosphere, shootouts, car theft, police chases, and mob missions. It is a linear crime drama, not a sandbox where you build your own criminal organisation.
The original game underneath is excellent.
The Definitive Edition part?
That is where someone walked into the evidence room carrying a suspiciously leaking bag.
Finished climbing the Mafia ladder? Good. Now go build an empire that actually pays the bills. Our GTA Online Weekly Money Guide tracks the best criminal opportunities, bonuses, and businesses before Los Santos turns your wallet into a crime scene. Because apparently even virtual criminals need a weekly financial advisor now.
What Is Mafia II: Definitive Edition?
Mafia II: Definitive Edition is the remastered version of the 2010 crime action game Mafia II. It includes the main story and all three DLC packs:
The Betrayal of Jimmy
Jimmy’s Vendetta
Joe’s Adventures
The game follows Vito Scaletta and his best friend Joe Barbaro as they work their way through Empire Bay’s criminal underworld during the 1940s and 1950s.
This is not a story about heroes saving the world.
Nobody here is collecting magical crystals, defeating ancient evil, or discovering the power of friendship.
Unless the power of friendship includes stealing cars, burying bodies, and trusting men whose retirement plans usually involve disappearing before court dates.
Mafia II is a gangster movie turned into a game.
That is both its biggest strength and its biggest limitation.
What Do You Actually Do In Mafia II?
Mafia II is a third-person action adventure game built around story missions.
Most gameplay involves:
Driving through Empire Bay
Working for Mafia families
Stealing vehicles
Fighting rival criminals
Escaping police
Using firearms
Completing criminal jobs
Following Vito’s rise through organised crime
The important thing to understand:
Empire Bay is not Los Santos.
The city is beautiful. The atmosphere is incredible. The cars, music, clothing, shops, weather, and streets sell the fantasy perfectly.
But it is mostly a stage for the story.
Mafia II built a fantastic criminal playground, then politely asks you to follow the script instead of immediately setting fire to the swings.
There are no businesses to buy.
No criminal empire management.
No endless side hustles.
The game wants you inside Vito’s story, not running around creating your own.
The Crime Gameplay: Is The Mafia Fantasy Actually Real?
Yes.
Very real.
Mafia II does not just put a fedora on a normal action game and call it organised crime.
The entire game revolves around the mob.
You work with criminal families.
You perform illegal jobs.
You steal.
You kill.
You climb through a violent hierarchy.
Vito is not secretly a good guy who occasionally parks badly.
He is a professional criminal.
A charming one, yes.
But charm does not magically erase the mountain of crimes sitting behind him. That mountain still exists. It just happens to be wearing an expensive coat.
Can You Play As The Bad Guy?
Yes, with one important warning.
You play as a criminal protagonist, but you do not choose your own evil path.
Mafia II is not an RPG.
You cannot decide:
“I would like to betray everyone, build a criminal empire, and become Emperor Tax Fraud the First.”
The story decides Vito’s journey.
You experience his rise, mistakes, consequences, and relationships.
The villain fantasy comes from being inside the Mafia world, not from choosing how evil you become.
Does Mafia II Have Heists?
Sort of.
There are robberies and major criminal operations, but Mafia II is not a dedicated heist game.
If you arrive expecting Payday-style planning, equipment choices, crew management, and perfect execution, you brought a blueprint to the wrong robbery.
Mafia II is about the life surrounding crime.
The loyalty.
The money.
The ambition.
The consequences.
The moment everyone in the room realises working with professional liars might have a tiny flaw in the business model.
The Wanted System And Police
Mafia II has a surprisingly detailed police system.
Commit crimes and the police react.
You can become wanted for actions like violence, theft, reckless driving, and other behaviour society unfairly labels as “massively illegal.”
Police can identify:
You
Your vehicle
Depending on the situation, avoiding trouble can involve hiding, changing clothes, replacing licence plates, or staying away until things cool down.
It creates a world where crime has consequences.
A shocking concept.
Apparently firing weapons in public attracts attention. Who could have predicted this except everyone.
The Best Thing About Mafia II: Atmosphere
This is where Mafia II becomes special.
Empire Bay feels alive.
Not because it has endless activities.
Because it has identity.
Snow covers the streets. Cars feel heavy. Music changes with the era. People dress differently. The city evolves.
The game understands something many giant open worlds forget:
A smaller world with personality beats a massive empty map filled with chores.
Some games give you 500 icons and somehow less to remember than a supermarket receipt.
Mafia II gives you a street corner, a car, and a conversation between two criminals, and somehow that sticks.
The Characters Carry Everything
Vito Scaletta and Joe Barbaro are the heart of Mafia II.
Their friendship gives the story weight.
Joe especially represents the seductive side of crime.
Money.
Parties.
Confidence.
Chaos.
The man approaches consequences like they are optional DLC.
The game works because it understands criminals are not interesting because they are evil.
They are interesting because they are human beings making terrible choices while convincing themselves everything is under control.
Which historically goes extremely well.
For approximately seventeen minutes.
The Biggest Problem: The Open World Is Limited
Empire Bay looks like a place where endless criminal opportunities should exist.
Then you realise most doors are locked.
The city is gorgeous.
But outside missions, there is not much meaningful criminal activity.
It is like being handed the keys to a luxury casino and discovering you are only allowed to use the vending machine.
This does not ruin Mafia II because the story is the focus.
But anyone expecting GTA-style freedom will feel restricted.
Vito Scaletta walked so every digital criminal with questionable morals could run. Continue the family business with our Best Heist Games Ranked and Best Crime Games Where You Play As The Villain lists. Warning: may cause sudden interest in expensive suits, suspicious meetings, and solving problems in extremely illegal ways.
The Definitive Edition Problem
Here comes the uncomfortable part.
Mafia II is excellent.
Mafia II: Definitive Edition is complicated.
The remaster improved some visual elements and includes all DLC, but it also introduced technical complaints that damaged its reputation.
Common player complaints include:
Performance problems
Visual glitches
Animation issues
Audio bugs
Crashes for some players
Less polish than expected
A remaster should preserve a classic.
At times, Mafia II: Definitive Edition feels like someone restored a vintage sports car, polished the paint, upgraded the seats, then accidentally installed a steering wheel made of cheese.
The car is still beautiful.
You just occasionally wonder who approved the cheese department.
Community Opinion
The general community verdict is surprisingly consistent:
The game?
Loved.
The remaster?
Complicated.
Players still praise:
The story
The characters
The atmosphere
The soundtrack
The Mafia setting
The complaints mostly target the Definitive Edition itself rather than Mafia II’s original design.
Underneath the technical problems is still one of the strongest crime stories in gaming.
The gangster survived.
The suit just got damaged.
Mafia II Compared To GTA
Mafia II and GTA are trying to do different things.
GTA gives you freedom.
Mafia II gives you focus.
GTA says:
“Here is a city. Destroy it responsibly.”
Mafia II says:
“Sit down. Wear this suit. Your terrible decisions begin at 8.”
If you want chaos, businesses, side activities, and unlimited crime opportunities, GTA wins.
If you want a focused Mafia story, Mafia II delivers something GTA usually avoids.
Mafia II Compared To Other Mafia Games
More polished remake.
Less of a criminal rise fantasy.
More open criminal systems.
More repetition.
More empire-building.
Less traditional Mafia atmosphere.
Each game commits different crimes.
Some against people.
Some against pacing.
Who Should Play Mafia II: Definitive Edition?
Play it if you want:
A serious Mafia story
A criminal protagonist
Gangster atmosphere
A focused campaign
Mob drama
Classic crime movies turned interactive
This is for people who want to sit at the table with criminals and watch everything slowly go wrong.
Who Should Skip It?
Skip it if you want:
A huge sandbox
Deep criminal management
Custom villain choices
Endless side activities
Modern open-world freedom
Mafia II gives you a story.
Not a criminal spreadsheet.
Your illegal organisation will not require weekly maintenance reports, supply chains, and enough admin work to make actual criminals consider getting normal jobs.
Final Verdict
Mafia II: Definitive Edition is a brilliant crime game inside a flawed package.
The story remains fantastic.
The characters still work.
The atmosphere is outstanding.
The criminal fantasy is genuine.
But the remaster should have treated the original like a priceless Mafia artifact instead of something found in a warehouse labelled “probably fine.”
It is still absolutely worth playing, especially on sale.
Just understand what you are buying:
Not GTA.
Not Payday.
Not crime simulator.
A focused gangster tragedy about ambition, loyalty, betrayal, and discovering that joining an organisation famous for murdering people may involve some workplace hazards.
Enjoy CRIMENET? Help keep the operation running through Ko-fi. Every contribution fuels more crime reports, villain investigations, and questionable career advice from fictional criminals.Join This Week in Crime for your weekly underworld briefing: the best crime games, broken updates, hidden opportunities, and industry decisions that deserve their own police investigation.Your next assignment: Best Crime Games to Play Right Now. The getaway car is already running.
FAQ
Is Mafia II: Definitive Edition worth playing?
Yes. Mafia II: Definitive Edition is worth playing for its story, characters, atmosphere, and Mafia setting. The main warning is that the remaster has technical issues.
Can you be a criminal in Mafia II?
Yes. You play as Vito Scaletta, a Mafia member involved in organised crime, theft, violence, and illegal jobs.
Is Mafia II like GTA?
Only partly. Both feature crime and open cities, but Mafia II is much more linear and story-focused.
Can you freely commit crimes in Mafia II?
You can commit crimes like stealing cars and fighting, but the game is not a full sandbox crime simulator. Most major criminal moments happen through missions.
Does Mafia II have heists?
Mafia II includes robberies and criminal missions, but it is not primarily a heist game.
Is Mafia II: Definitive Edition better than the original?
Not always. The Definitive Edition includes all DLC and visual changes, but many players prefer aspects of the original because of remaster-related issues.
Is Mafia II still good in 2026?
Yes. Its storytelling and atmosphere have aged extremely well, even though the open-world design and remaster quality show their age.
Comments